1. Skip to Menu
  2. Skip to Content
  3. Skip to Footer>

Hotlinks:

  • 4 US troops killed in eastern Afghanistan

    Four U.S. troops were killed in fighting in eastern and southern Afghanistan on Sunday, and a former guerrilla leader who battled Soviet invaders decades ago was killed by a roadside bomb in the country's north.

  • Wikileaks: Pentagon may be behind rape claims

    Wikileaks founder Julian Assange said in an interview published on Sunday that he believes the Pentagon could be behind a rape accusation against him that was later dropped by Swedish prosecutors.

  • Nuke: Iran President willing to meet West halfway

    TEHRAN--Iran is ready to resume talks with six major powers on nuclear issues as early as this month, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Thursday during an exclusive interview with The Yomiuri Shimbun.

  • Japan War simulation aims to send China signal

    The Self-Defense Forces will conduct exercises simulating the recapture of an isolated island from enemy forces in December, Defense Ministry sources said, the first such drills by the SDF and seen as a response to China's recent naval expansion.

  • NATO Expands Onshore Role In Somalia

    NATO anti-piracy operation officials on the Somali coast had reached Hobyo district, an ancient harbor city in the Mudug region of Somalia which is 50-KM away from Galkaio the provisional capital of the Mudug region in central Somalia.

Floods expose civilian-military divide in Pakistan

PDF Print E-mail


ISLAMABAD – Massive flooding in Pakistan has added to criticism of the already-weak civilian government while boosting the image of the military, a potential blow to U.S. and domestic hopes of fostering a strong Pakistani democracy after years of army rule. Even before the crisis began nearly a month ago, the government faced discontent as power shortages, Islamist militant violence and economic mismanagement plagued the country. A military coup is seen as unlikely, but flooding is so large-scale that some fear political instability in the nuclear-armed nation.

About 20 million people have been affected by the floods across an area bigger than England. Flood victims are far more likely to have seen a Pakistani soldier dropping off relief or picking them up than a member of the civilian government. One state minister's car was pelted with stones after a visit some saw as long overdue, media reports said.

"The overwhelming majority of Pakistanis have always reposed confidence in the army as compared to elected governments," said Mehdi Hasan, a Pakistani political analyst. "People feel the army can do better as it is well trained, it has time and the courage to handle any crisis. It gives an edge to the army over the civil administration."

The army ruled Pakistan for more than half of its 63-year history, thanks to coups that followed periods of political unrest or economic mismanagement by civilian leaders. The government today has been in place less than three years, after nearly a decade of army rule by then-Gen. Pervez Musharraf.

But the army has retained tremendous independence, to the point where many Pakistanis speak of the government and the military as separate entities. It also has steadily regained the popularity it lost during Musharraf's tenure. In 2009, its operations against the Taliban in the Swat Valley and South Waziristan tribal region had broad public support.

The civilians' initial response appeared chaotic and confused as the flooding disaster unfolded. But symbolism seemed to matter more: President Asif Ali Zardari's decision to visit France and England as people fled their water-filled homes infuriated many and burnished the image of an out-of-touch political elite.

More recently, the front pages of Pakistani newspapers have been filled with bickering between the ruling party and the opposition over how flood relief should be monitored, and whether additional layers of bureaucracy should be established to oversee the aid.

The army has been stretched by the crisis, too, but it has exhibited more discipline and message control. It is the only institution in Pakistan capable of large-scale relief work, with some 60,000 troops involved in helping flood victims. It is also running numerous relief camps and delivering aid to the stranded.

Nisar Ahmed, 26, and his father first sent the women and children in their family away with army rescuers. Eventually, the water got too high for them to stay and protect their home in Hamdani Legari village of Sindh province. The men used a tractor to trek 2.5 miles (4 kilometers) in the water to a large dirt embankment where an army truck was distributing food.

"Of course, it is the army helping the people. The government never helps at a bad time," Ahmed said. "We only see politicians when they come here to ask for votes, but then they disappear."

Earlier this month, crowds threw stones at junior economic affairs minister Hina Rabbani Khar's convoy when it arrived in her flood-hit constituency in Muzzafargarh district of Punjab province. Had she bothered to visit before, the residents said, they would have asked her to do something about breaches in a nearby canal, Dawn newspaper reported.

Army spokesmen could not immediately be reached for comment. Pakistani civilian leaders, however, insist they are doing their best to deal with a calamity that would have overwhelmed many governments.

Pakistan's ambassador to the U.S. said hostile segments of the local press have whipped up imaginary tensions between the army and the civilian leadership. The ruling party enjoys excellent relations with the generals, Husain Haqqani said, downplaying the possibility of a government fall.

"Notwithstanding our history, our military recognizes the need for maintaining the primacy of the constitution," said Haqqani.

Most countries use their military in times of natural disaster — it has helicopters, boats and the manpower to help. Even the U.S. experienced failures in dealing with just one flooded city, New Orleans, during Hurricane Katrina, observers say.

But asked who is in charge of relief — the army or the civilians — and talk is of cooperation, not chain of command.

"It's a partnership," said Salman Taseer, the governor of Punjab province. "The civilian government is raising international funds. The civilian government is providing a lot of support. The army has, of course, the logistical ability. I think it's a great example of civilian and army working together."

The U.S. has tried to shore up Pakistani democracy, seeing it as a means of ending popular support for Islamist militants and empowering ordinary citizens. A five-year, $7.5 billion U.S. aid package for Pakistan is partly aimed at strengthening civilian institutions in the country.

During a visit to Pakistan on Thursday, U.S. Sen. John Kerry said the flooding crisis could present an opportunity for the civilian government to build capacity and improve its skills — a "silver lining" to the tragedy.

"Crisis often strengthens a government," he said.

___

Associated Press writers Tim Sullivan in Kachero and Munir Ahmed in Islamabad contributed to this report.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Quote this article on your site

To create link towards this article on your website,
copy and paste the text below in your page.




Preview :


Powered by QuoteThis © 2008
Comments (0)

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Today's Exclusive

US and Israel forcing a done deal on Fatah
21/08/2010 | kazi mahmood
article thumbnail

In a plot that smells 'Zionism' and American desperation, the US State Secretary office is trying to shaft into the Fatah's throat a plan to undermine Hamas as the legitimate representatives of the Pa [ ... ]


US-EU and Their All-OUT Colonial Wars
22/07/2010 | kazi mahmood
article thumbnail

Has Europe and the USA really moved on from the age old 'colonial' endeavors that fashioned their cultures and thinking and built their economies in the past?


Other Articles

Advertisement

 


 



Hotels In Dubai


 

 

IceCarousel

Cindy Sheehan on CIA extrajudicial killings in Pakistan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3QumrijBIk&feature=player_embedded#
Long-time anti-war activist Cindy Sheehan is now speaking out against drone activities in Pakistan. She sat down with Kristine Frazao to talk about how extrajudicial CIA actions are mostly affecting civilians in remote tribal regions.

The other War: Information War by Taliban

http://salamkhan.blip.tv/

Click on the link above to watch this interesting video that shows how the information wars is being fought, the Taliban way.

Video: Is the battle for Jerusalem over?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iz1SJnQe1fE&feature=player_embedded

As EU Foreign ministers prepare to meet on Monday to discuss a Swedish proposal to recognise Jerusalem as the capital of both Israel and Palestine, the EU accuses Israel of working deliberately to alter the citys demographic balance and sever East Jerusalem from the West Bank. Can the EU play a role in peace making after being marginalised for so long? Or is the battler for Jerusalem already over?

Video: German sovereignty restricted by US

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGjkQAa9I34&feature=player_embedded

The former head of the West German Military Intelligence has issued a book revealing secret details of a 1949 US-German treaty, alleging America and its allies have been deliberately suppressing the nations sovereignty.

Gerry Adams supports Free Gaza Movement

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX0pCSfesKo&NR=1

I am sure Gerry Adams speaks for the whole of Ireland and the fact that he is wishing well the Rachel Corrie aid ship and the flotilla of ships and boats heading right now to Gaza is great. I hope other MP's offer their support too.
With the help of public donations an abandoned 1200 ton cargo ship has been bought and loaded with vital supplies to help the Palestinian people in Gaza. This ship was renamed The Rachel Corrie and is on it's way to Gaza.

'Israel is a Lunatic State' - Finkelstein

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eB_CKL5h2_8

Political scientist Norman Finkelstein has spoken to RT to give his assessment of Israel's raid on the Gaza Freedom Flotilla.

Video: Obama OK Troops Surge in Afghan War

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYb4I1bOsVA&feature=player_embedded

President Obama has tentatively decided to send thousands of additional troops to Afghanistan per Gen. Stanley McChrystal's request. David Martin reports.

For Muslim consumption: Video of Kabul Attacks

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3BI2h-cxHI&feature=youtube_gdata

George Galloway: Part 2 Of His PWTC Speech

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXjfciPvP5o

Video: Rachel Corrie Seized

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QrycaoGllWg&feature=youtu.be

June 04, 2010  — The Israeli Navy has seized a new Gaza-bound aid ship Rachel Corrie following its earlier attack on the Gaza Freedom Flotilla, according to activists.

 

Genies in a bottle

Eyes in Sky - This video will really scare you

Watch Video Here

Though we do not really know who took the videos and where it originates, we have the information that it was taken after the Indonesian earthquake in Padang, Riau. If you look patiently at the video, you will see a pair of eyes that is formed in the clouds overlooking a village in Indonesia. It will really shock and scare you!

However, apparently this video was taken a few years ago in Russia. Hence the source is unknown and the location too but it is a very real video, not a graphic picture.

A 'crawling Jin' in the street?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBQjfCo3kL4

Click here to watch the video

Is this a Jin crawling in the street in Palestine? The author who posted the video on Youtube has this to say: "This video came from first source of busines's security camera in Rahat - palstine. 

Video: Singapore's haunted condominiums

France: Jinn going to Masjid?

Jinns in a bottle - true story